Every January, so many of us set a running resolution with the best intentions. The motivation lasts for a week or two… and then weather, fatigue, or life catches up. By February, most resolutions quietly fade, and it’s not because of lack of discipline or willpower. They fail for surprisingly predictable reasons.
It’s not laziness or lack of effort. The problem is usually the way the goal is set: too intense, too broad, or simply disconnected from real life. If you’ve struggled to stay consistent in the past, nothing is wrong with you – the system you were following just wasn’t designed to build a habit that lasts.
In my last post, New Year’s running resolutions guide, we focused on building a routine that fits busy, real-life schedule. Let’s now take a look at the seven reasons most New Year’s running resolution fail, and how to avoid most common mistakes. No guilt, no pressure – just simple, realistic steps you can take today.
1. Doing too much too soon
The classic January pattern looks the same for so many people: the excitement is high, the motivation is fresh, and the urge to finally make it stick this year often leads to pushing far too much. A sudden jump in mileage or pace might feel productive in the moment, but for unprepared muscles and tendons, it’s simply too much impact too soon.
By the second or third week, all that enthusiasm often turns into soreness, frustration, or nagging aches that make running hard to keep up with. This is truly one of the most common reasons running resolutions fail – the effort is far higher than your body is ready for.
How to avoid it
Start with run-walk intervals. They’re the most effective and beginner-friendly way to build endurance without overwhelming your muscles, joints, or cardiovascular system.
Keep the pace intentionally slow. If you can’t hold a conversation, ease up until your breathing feels steady.
Use a gentle, structured plan. A simple schedule removes the guesswork and lets you progress gradually.
The goal in January isn’t speed or distance, but building a routine and giving your body the time to adapt to it.
If you want an easy place to start, try my 4-week habit-building beginner running plan – it’s designed for busy women who want to build a habit without pressure or burnout.
2. Setting unrealistic goals
“Run more”. “Get fit”. “New Year new me”.
A lot of New Year’s running resolutions sound inspiring in the moment, but they don’t actually guide your behaviour. When a goal is too vague, too broad, or too rigid, it’s almost set up to fail.
Unrealistic expectations create pressure that makes a new habit almost impossible to maintain long-term. When the plan is too demanding or overwhelming, motivation fades quickly, and the resolution falls apart long before the new routine has a chance to stick.
How to avoid it
Set a clear, flexible goal. Aim for 2–3 short runs per week at the beginning.
Choose routine over performance. In January, your only job is showing up, not running fast or far.
Make your goal match your real life. Short, achievable sessions win over big, unsustainable promises.
The most sustainable running goals are clear, realistic, and flexible enough to adjust around your real life. Think of January as the time to build the consistency and confidence, not hit the performance targets.
Read more: Realistic running goals for the New Year.
3. All-or-nothing mindset
The all-or-nothing mindset is one of the most common reasons why running resolutions fail. You miss one run, believe you’ve ruined the whole plan, and decide to start over next Monday. But motivation might not make it until Monday, and before you know it, your goal starts to fade.
Life always gets in the way – work deadlines, illness, bad weather conditions, or simply a busy schedule. A rigid resolution can’t survive real life, and chasing perfection is the quickest way to give up altogether.
How to avoid it
Plan your week in pencil, not pen. Let the plan bend without breaking.
Remember that one missed run isn’t a failure. Reschedule, shorten, switch to an active rest day if needed – it all counts.
Focus on progress, not perfection. It’s the sum over weeks and months that creates real change.
A sustainable habit leaves room for flexibility. You don’t need to follow your plan exactly to make progress. You just need to keep showing up in a way that fits the day you’re having.
4. Relying only on motivation
In the first days of the New Year, motivation runs high. By week three however, it often disappears in the noise of daily chores. Motivation comes and goes – habits, on the other hand, are there to stay. They carry you forward even when you’re tired, busy, or simply not in the mood.
For busy women especially, relying on inspiration alone can lead to frustration and guilt. With work, family responsibilities, and an endless to-do list, waiting to “feel motivated” almost guarantees that your running resolution won’t last past January.
How to avoid it
Use habit triggers. Lay out your clothes the night before, block a specific time in your calendar, or connect your run to an existing routine.
Pair runs with something enjoyable. Save a favourite playlist, podcast, or an audiobook just for running. Make running something you genuinely look forward to.
Support your routine with small rewards. Create a cozy post-run ritual – warm shower, favourite coffee, gentle stretching. These tiny actions create a positive feedback loop that keeps you going even when motivation dips.
Track your progress. Log your runs: distance, time, or simply how you felt. Seeing your progress visually helps build sense of achievement, and stay motivated long-term.
You don’t need to feel motivated every day to stay consistent. When you create a simple system for yourself, showing up becomes almost automatic, even on difficult days.
Read more: Winter running motivation guide.
5. Winter weather conditions
In January, the season itself sets running resolutions up for failure. Dark mornings, cold temperatures, and icy paths make it much harder to stick to a plan. On top of that, the lack of sunlight in winter can lower your energy and affect your mood , which makes getting out the door even more challenging.
If your plan doesn’t account for the weather, it can fall apart fast – not because you lack motivation or willpower, but simply because you’re unprepared for difficult conditions.
How to avoid it
Build a winter-resistant strategy. Pick familiar routes, try to run in daylight, and think about indoor options for the worst days. The right winter gear can also make a huge difference in comfort and confidence – see my Winter running layering guide.
Adapt your plan to the weather. Move sessions around when the forecast suddenly changes – a Tuesday run still counts on Wednesday.
A running habit that survives winter is built on flexibility, not perfection. When you adapt your plan to the season you’re in, consistency becomes much more manageable – even on the darkest, chilliest days.
Read more: Winter running guide: cold weather tips and gear.
6. Ignoring rest, recovery, and fueling
New Year often comes with pressure to “start strong”, which can quickly lead to frustration, burnout, or even injury. Underfueling, skipping warm-ups, or pushing through fatigue are common reasons why running resolutions fail.
Many beginners believe that rest means losing progress. In reality, it’s the opposite: without recovery, your body doesn’t have the time it needs to adapt to impact of running.
How to avoid it
Treat rest as part of training. Rest days aren’t optional – they’re where your body repairs, adapts, and gets stronger.
Prioritise recovery with small, daily actions. A few minutes of stretching, mobility work, or gentle foam rolling can make a bigger impact than inconsistent “big” efforts. See my Running recovery routine for women for simple, time-saving strategies.
Fuel properly. Avoid running fasted. Have a small, high-carb snack before your run and include protein afterwards to support muscle repair. Read more in my Pre-run nutrition guide.
Ease into impact gradually. Give your muscles, joints, and tendons time to adjust. The slower you build, the more sustainable your progress becomes.
Taking care of your body is what keeps you moving forward. When you support it with enough rest, fuel, and recovery, staying consistent with running becomes far easier – and far more enjoyable.
7. No accountability or support system
When enthusiasm dips – and it always does at some point – you need something more to keep you going. Without some form of accountability, even the best plan can quietly disappear by the end of January. A little support truly goes a long way.
Accountability doesn’t mean pressure. It simply gives your running habit a bit of structure and connection – enough to help you stay consistent without feeling judged or overwhelmed.
How to avoid it
Find a running buddy. Ask a friend or join a local run club. Having someone expect you, even just once a week, adds natural commitment, and makes your new routine far easier to maintain. The social aspect can turn running into something you genuinely look forward to, instead of something you negotiate with yourself.
Find online support. Use Strava or join a beginner-friendly online community. Light social accountability can be surprisingly effective. A simple “kudos”, weekly check-in, or sharing your progress offers encouragement without pressure. It’s a reminder that you’re not doing this alone, even if you run solo.
A running habit becomes much easier when you’re not doing it in isolation. With even a little support, running can turn into a consistent part of your daily schedule.
FAQ: why running resolutions fail
Motivation naturally fades once the initial excitement wears off and daily routines return. Short winter days, cold weather, and busy schedules make running feel harder, especially if the plan is too intense or rigid. That’s why January enthusiasm often dips by week three – it’s not a lack of willpower, but a sign that the routine wasn’t designed to be sustainable.
The biggest mistakes are starting too fast, setting vague or unrealistic goals, relying only on motivation, ignoring recovery, and expecting perfection. These patterns quickly lead to burnout or discouragement. Instead, focus on small, repeatable habits, flexible planning, and gradual progression – these are the foundations of a running routine that lasts.
A clear plan removes guesswork and makes running feel easier to stick to. When you know what you’re doing each week, you’re less likely to overdo it, get overwhelmed, or talk yourself out of it.. A simple, beginner-friendly structure gives your body time to adapt and helps running become a natural part of your routine, not another source of pressure.
New Year’s running resolution that lasts
New Year’s running resolutions don’t fail because of laziness or lack of willpower. They fail because they are build on pressure instead of structure. A gentle, flexible approach works far better than trying to “start strong” and hold onto motivation that naturally fades.
Small habits, realistic goals, and a little patience will take you further than January excitement alone ever could. Focus on showing up for yourself in a way that fits your lifestyle, and fitness, endurance, and confidence will follow.
Try New Year’s running challenge: 10 minutes a day to build a habit!
Read more:
• 4-week habit-building beginner running plan
• New Year’s running resolutions guide
• Realistic running goals for the New Year
Want weekly support and motivation?
Join The Extra Mile newsletter down below for new posts notifications and weekly running tips – straight to your inbox.
